WordPress theme reject, can't see any reason :)

rabbitstudios · August 25, 2024, 7:47am

Can anybody give me a clear explanation? Thank you!

Made with Vanilla JS, TailwindCSS, WebSocket, WebRTC and PHP 8.X+

This is a Theme that uses it’s own core plugin to provide;

Story system
Live broadcasting via WebSocket (PubNub)
Live PM, voice and video calls
Reels System
Exploration System
Community system (reddit like, community owner can set their sidebars and everything.)
User system (reddit like)
Post sharing over PM system
Story answers over PM system
Live notifications via WebSocket
Very detailed post creator ( Can’t even explain, with tons of good feature)

You can even create your own reactions from reaction creator

etc… etc…

The only products that can be considered as competitors are buddypress products. I really don’t understand why, since these products are sold with completely bad/half designs with lots of unstyled buttons, including XSS vulnerabilities.

Demo: https://white.rabbit.pw
Docs: https://docs.rabbit.pw/

ApexCodeStudios · August 26, 2024, 3:47pm

This is Truly a Great Great product with the Greatest Design Ever

Sadly for an Item to be approved on Envato

The item must be unique - Bring something new to the Marketplace
The item must have a great design
The item must be able to sell - Will the item have buyers???

I know it’s frustrating to work on a product and then get Rejected, somebody should start a new Marketplace because many Top Level Products are being rejected on a daily basis.

FWDesign · August 26, 2024, 4:08pm

I see your technical data sheet nobody really cares about that in 2024 specially the response time that was a bad move in my opinion, two years ago this would have been approved, if you had improved the designs o be more modern I think the technical aspect is really good you should have a chance…

rabbitstudios · August 26, 2024, 4:09pm

Thank you for your reply!

Almos everything is totally unique in this theme. There is Rabbit Hole plugin much much stronger than BuddyPress. This product is not only a theme its a system. I never seen a all in one system that has these features. If you register and check, you will see whay im trying to say…

Design, its fully developed with tailwindcss and its a modern and mature. I mean, when I check buddypress themes, I finds my product much better. But its only for me I guess

And about the buyers, everybody trying to escape from buddypress. Rabbit (our plugin) is the best alternative right now.

Im still trying to figure it out why this is rejected so I can fix the issues…

FWDesign · August 26, 2024, 4:12pm

You should listen to us veterans here, your opinion is irrelevant, the reviewer’s opinion matters if you wat to sell here.

ApexCodeStudios · August 26, 2024, 4:14pm

I see your technical data sheet nobody really cares

I don’t think I am getting you here.

rabbitstudios · August 26, 2024, 4:18pm

Hello! When I check latest buddypress themes (because these are the only closest examples), I dont see anything bad. Can you check them? Almost all of them have bad aligned buttons, no padding buttons, bad constrat fore and backgrounds.

For an example, metafans?

All of them have even unstyled raw html buttons that they forgat to style.

Try to change your profile picture on the Rabbit and on any buddypress theme.

Did anybody created a fully secure WebRTC based live broadcasting? Live voice and video calls with P2P system before?

Make critics on my theme, yes. BUT, by only saying “your design would be accepted if it have a modern design” your are unseeing its “unique” features. And please tell me, what can I do to make this design looks better.

Did you check VK? Instagram? Reddit? All of them have basic non fancy designs. Why? To make people focus on the user’s content…

Buddypress themes? All of them are buggy. Slow.

All of them are even hackable. For an example, I can easily sql injection or xss MetaFans theme.

Is this the quality standart of Envato?

If you have thoughts about how I can make this theme look better please give me advices. But sorry, Rabbit is FAR away good coded compared to the market. Optimized and engineered theme ever seen on Envato.

Its 0 query theme without static cache, it uses full of special object caching and even have a built in PCC system (pesimistic concurrency controller to handle really really huge concurrent mysql updates).

Im so sorry for my aggresive reply. But compared to buddypress themes, my theme is much much better. Im not trying to be egomaniac but you can check best seller buddypress themes.

It feels, envato doesnt cares performance, features, bad coding, bad practices, sql injections, xss vulns. It only cares HOW IT LOOKS and if its design feels lile 2022 it throws it to the trash.

“Lets accept a theme that have 200 query on homepage, worst UX, cant handle even 100 concurrent online user cuz of high mysql usage, no xdebugged and have xss vulns (so customers can get hacked), BUT HEY YOU KNOW WHAT? ITS A 2024 DESIGN!”

Again, if you have any specific advices for the design please lead me the way.

FWDesign · August 26, 2024, 5:16pm

Check the latest approved items in the past two months the old ones do not matter and they can’t be removed because there are clients that use them and need updated support, so compare your work with the latest approved in the past two months in your category if you don’t come to something new feature-wise and design wise it will not be approved, the techincal details should work out of the box you don’t need to list them a client dose not care about ms load times and other stuff like this… you are selling a product you have to make it commercial and appealing otherwise it will not sell…

This is how Envato works, I created one theme worked on it for one year, and got a hard reject I almost cried

It took me six more months to remake it and it was approved but I will never ever do a theme again, I stick with plugins…

rabbitstudios · August 26, 2024, 7:22pm

When I check latest approved BuddyPress themes (because BuddyPress is the only close plugin to my system); I’m seeing these:

I can take alots of more screenshots. No placeholders, massive padding and margin problems, bad icons, flex-out menus etc etc etc…

Would you accept them?

I’m so sorry but; I still can’t find the reason for my rejection.

I’m still looking for a person to lead me. To tell me the reason.

Why anyone would reject this theme? If it’s design quality; tell me what I’m doing wrong. Because when I check latest approved BuddyPress themes; they have some good places yes; but overall or when you look their details; they are buggy and feels uncompleted.