Why My Product Reject Now ?

Envato Authors Theme Authors
1

Hello ,

This is secoud time my secoud product is Hard Reject … Why without telling any point for improvement ?

Item link : http://testing.dexignlab.com/kelsey/test1/

Please check and give a proper reason why this product should hard reject ?

Thanks
DexignZone

2

You have the features and pages etc but the execution is nit great

  • colours make it feel outdated

  • more than anything typography and hierarchy in your styling needs work

3

thanks for reply but PSD and HTML both is already approved :


and we were thinking that design is cool according to personal blog … and if there is some design issue … themeforest should tell us clear that item has design issue … at-lease they should give 1 chance to survive …

We have testing Responsive … Theme Unit Test … Gutenberg Block Tests and everything which we could do and which was in our mind …

This is my 3rd item was hard rejected … it’s really not good … :persevere:

Hope for some good suggestions …

Thanks

4

Unfortunately, the expectation and standards are higher for WP esp. in such a crowded category

5

Again , my questions is the design not good ?

Is my theme hard rejected for design side ? Or there are any coding mistake ?

I have checked all new items in category with low quality images and dull designs elements , even they have lots of designs issues in normal responsive testing … But yes all that items are related to Elite Authors … ?? Is this a reason ?

After hard reject , a author can’t upload item after change design ?

6

It can be resubmitted with significant changes.

I can’t comments in detail on the code but I do think (in my view) that the design could be improved esp given the extent of competition in the blog category.

You could try reaching out to support and asking if they will provide more info

Did you mention in the submission that PSD and HMTL was approved?

7

Yes, I mentioned this.

8

Hi There,

You have the framework and all the options / features, now create a different design, because this one will not be accepted.

Good luck with the next one and don’t give up.
If you get a hard reject, move to next, like that, you’ll improve a lot.

Edit: as for your question, Yes, first, the design is the problem. No one will take a look at the options / features of the theme, if the design is not up to date. And yours looks outdated, sorry.

9

Thanks a lot @An-Themes and @charlie4282 to give me valuable suggestion.

Will you please check now : http://testing.dexignlab.com/kelsey/test1/

We have changes theme and resolve all minor issues with changed all all images to give theme different look and feel. Now changed theme color also … purpal.

Please check and give me suggestion … is it ready to submit now ?

Thanks
DexignZone

10

Thanks a lot @An-Themes and @charlie4282 to give me valuable suggestion.

Will you please check now : http://testing.dexignlab.com/kelsey/test1/

We have changes theme and resolve all minor issues with changed all all images to give theme different look and feel. Now changed theme color also … purpal.

Please check and give me suggestion … is it ready to submit now ?

Thanks
DexignZone

11

Looks more better now.
But still: https://d.pr/free/i/IolVv4 https://d.pr/free/i/soK5PR https://d.pr/free/i/jLuUiK

12

Thanks again …

Can you please tell us browser name where you are getting overlap post block issue ?

In last one we want to use simple footer like this … Is there any design issue ?

Thanks

13

…

  • It happens only when you click “Load More” in Firefox and Chrome, I guess you’ll get the same issue in all browsers.
14

We have checked that issue and resolve asap and uploaded again …

Again I gor HARD REJECT … Really don’t know why ?

Reviewer Message :-

Thank you for your submission. We have completed our review of “Kelsey - Personal Blog WordPress Template” and unfortunately we found it isn’t at the quality standard required to move forward, and you won’t be able to re-submit this item again.

We appreciate the effort and time you’ve put into creating your item. And we’d be happy to help make sure your next entry will meet our submission requirements. Here’s our advice:

Visit our forums and ask fellow authors for feedback. Our helpful community will be glad to lend a hand.

Check out this Help Center article to understand why and how items get rejected.

Remember you can get help, in the form of tutorials or skilled professionals, on Envato Tuts+ and Envato Studio.

We hope to see a new submission from you soon!

Item Demo Link : http://testing.dexignlab.com/kelsey/test1/

Now I want to know comment of 10+ Authors why my item is hard reject ? I have mentioned that we are3 ready to do changes if you told us. … really not getting reviewers/themeforest behaviors …

please help and I want authors comment on this … don’t know how other author will check this and give me suggestion …

@An-Themes @charlie4282 thanks for your replies , how can other author notice on this ?

15

I actually came across the preview of your website, I should see the Unit Test Theme.

To be honest, your theme has a big design problems - I have feel this design sense that there is no concept from the beginning so there is no guide style for it:

  • typography
  • spacing
  • consistency
  • visual hierarchy
  • color
    and many more…

Here are some photos you can see:
https://screenpresso.com/=Eii4f
https://screenpresso.com/=dUaBg
https://screenpresso.com/=FwBZb
https://screenpresso.com/=vvkJf
https://screenpresso.com/=NNfze

Hope you can design a new version better

1 Like
16

Thank you for your detailed reviews. Really very helpful.

17

Hello Friends,

After reading all things and design related article we decide to improvement our design and resubmit again. and We have resubmitted 3rd time after lot’s of changes again.

I would like to request all Authors to give some feedback from your sides also.

Demo link : http://kelsey.dexignzone.com/wp/

Thanks
DexignZone

19

This type of error on no of products in envato products that approved… if you list i provide you… then my question is why approved this products?

1 Like
20

Hello All,

After many changes in design and new development on theme now please check : https://kelsey.dexignzone.com/wp2020/

I just submit this and again after one soft reject they HARD REJECT it ?

I am really surprised and want to know reason of HARD Reject so we could resolve that and upload again.

Thanks
DexignZone

21

Hello,

This is the five time my five product is Hard Reject … Why without telling any point for improvement?

Item link : http://www.fatimakhatun.com/Piroll/

Please check and give a proper reason why this product should hard to reject ?

Thanks