They look childish and unprofessional in my opinion. I see that Envato wanted to modernize the old ones, but this just isn’t the right approach
That’s what a lot of people said about the previous designs, but I really, really don’t like these new ones now. They look like a colourful mess of generic, simplified icons and their charm is gone. I’d really like to see Envato bring back the old ones. They were great. If you want to vote to bring them back, check out my “bring back the old badges poll” thread.
Please leave feedback over in the announcement post here: Redesigned Community Badges Now Live!