They rejected me the last 3 items that I included in AJ, and I do not understand why. It’s been a while since I started uploading music here and I’m seeing that it’s getting harder.
the message was:
“Thank you for your submission. We have completed our review of “Christmas” and unfortunately we found it at the required standard to move forward, and you will not be able to re-submit this item again.”
Here is the comment from your Envato Quality team reviewer:
This item does not meet the general commercial quality standard required to be accepted on AudioJungle, unfortunately.
Thank you for taking the time to submit content to AudioJungle.
Hey, its not bad, but I think its too long and not so much interesting because its kind of repeating. If this was a short one would be approved. But also I notice some dissonant clashing things, maybe bad notes from bell sound playing together with some bad notes from other instruments
I think you need to seriously work on the mix. There are also many dissonances.
If offended sorry, I did not want to. I wish you success!
Thank you very much for answering, I was with some things so I came back late, sorry.
I will take what you advise me, but the truth is that it becomes very difficult to know when something will meet the requirements of aj. Maybe the bells … But to say that it is commercial standars would not be more things of the style, I do not know.
I’m also losing expectations of aj…
Thank you very much for answering!
You say it can be for the bells? although they make dissonances I thought they were part of the style.
How do you listen to the mix? Do instruments listen well? the compression? brightness? volume? I thank many of these opinions. Thank you!!
Definitely too long in length, not enough changes in the melody for it to be a 2+ minute track. The main bell needs better mixing, it’s flat and cheap sounding. Try a better bell sound and add a nice reverb to it, currently it’s way too bright and pierces through the entire track. Melody is catchy though…just shorten the entire track down and try another bell and add more reverb to the strings (take some low end out after you do).
AJ don’t like disbalance in pan. Maybe i’m wrong, but for me bells moved little bit to right. For solo melody it’s bad. And trombone, as for me, got the same promlem.