My First Item in Graphic River is REJECTED!! Feeling Upset.

graphics

#1

I have worked hard to build a magazine temple. But after uploading the template they rejected after 4 days. They told me in their email that the quality isn’t standard required to move forward, and I won’t be able to re-submit this item again. I am really feeling upset.

Please help to rectify my error. I am attracting the file zip.


#2

hi firts of all u have a technical issue as u are not supposed to included the model …apart from this , this is not a “magazine template” that u have here but the template of a magazine cover , which is completely different, as u have only one page in the zip file … in addition , according to me , your cover is a bit too monolithic … there is nothing really popping out in the end , this is the same color everywhere, u do not have graphic elements at all but red texts. It seems to me that u could by the way find more harmonious typo combinations again and the whole thing in a general way is a bit too flat, too rough or too raw. Do not get me wrong i do not mean that this is really not good all teh way but the fact of the matter is that u have a lot of things lacking at this stage all the same, hopefully, with a bit more effort u can make it reach the next level and have it approved :slight_smile:


#3

my friend

first thing -> when you are upset play Bob Marley music

Second thing -> Imagine you are Envato elements Contributor (I am) - you can upload your items without any review -> BUT -> your portfolio is reviewed from time to time - at first review I got about 50 items deleted, Items which were accepted on graphicriver - Imagine how I feel then :slight_smile:

Third thing -> never give up - after someone from stuff deleted my items I uploaded twice more :slight_smile: and finally I saw $$$$ when earning report came

don’t worry :slight_smile: be stoned :slight_smile: ehehhee


#4

@Novocaina

my friend, let’s face it , at this stage , this is not surprising if Purkait had his item rejected …
once this is said, joining elements is not given to all people as envato people are selecting who is part of it and i was not chosen lol i guess a lot of authors will not be able to join either …


#5

Thanks for your support. I will think every point you said and make my product better next time. Do you have any suggestions?


#6

Yeah! I love BOB Marley. And your story is too inspiring. Can you share your portfolio?


#7

my suggestion? do not do next time, do now lol hahahah


#8

Envato elements is hard to control, ju have thousands or tens of thousand item added every week and envato elements team have to cotroll all of them soonner or later - So I thing they are letting there some new authors from time to time but they can’t approve all authors because they couldn’t control the quality.

Many times I saw webste templates in print category - some authors are cheating to be more visible there and envato have to deal with this.

I suggest you fill the form twice a month and you chances will increase. ;]