Yea, it’s a little strange that they accepted one, but rejected the other. Though I guess it also could have been two different reviewers with different personal tastes… which of course isn’t very good, but it seems to be the case quite often on GraphicRiver.
Maybe try to make a more interesting preview? The thumbnail that you have for the accepted one is more interesting than the actual preview image. You could even show some examples of the graphics being used in different situations. I think this will automatically make the quality look far better.
If you decide to do this, then I think you shouldn’t have a problem resubmitting it, since it should look drastically different.
lol i have seen it all ever since i am here … so nothing is making me feel surprised anymore … i have had a declination of an accepted product rejected when all the others had been approved and were doing very well … as for what u mentioned as regard to presentation , this is clearly not an option but mandatory and i am even wandering one could go through with such a presentation but this makes people feel bad if they see two lookalike things one making it and one not going through …