Hey @golden_cursor
You’ve hit one of the grand challenges of running a huge marketplace like Envato. This is the fact that we currently can’t provide the kind of in-depth feedback that our reviewers would probably really like to give.
There are so many items submitted to the queue that there just isn’t the time. If we were to take this approach, the entire review queue would slow down, and the wait time for review would be enormous. It’s not a perfect system, but it’s the one we currently have.
There’s also the issue of subjectivity. There are many different reviewers, and as with all art, there is some variance. Sometimes it can also be to do with an over-supply of items that look very similar to your own, rather than an issue of quality per-say.
Nobody here- even me- is going to be able to give you exact reasons. The community can give you feedback about how you might improve the overall standard, but at the end of the day, the only way to improve your odds is to keep improving the overall quality of your work 