Css item has been rejected

Envato Authors CodeCanyon
1

Hello to everyone,

The design I made was not accepted by Envato. What’s wrong with you? Can you help me with the following links?

Thank you.

http://saltkod.com/navbar/simple-navbar.html Demo Link

http://saltkod.com/navbar/documentation.html Documentation Link

2

The rejection reason is clear to me. Your item is too basic and simple. The premium feeling is missing all the way.

Try to take a look at some approved items and learn how to improve this one.

Regards

3

But still, this was an item to css scripts right?!
So lets take a look at something… This is simple! Right!
But… probably @saltkod wouldn’t go for an high value. Probably he would request about $5 or so, and what does this would get to him?| With all the taxes… $2?
So why couldn’t this item be accepted? He lost time developing it, and also created a documentation for it? For $2 isn’t worth it? As I’ve replied on the other topic… Why not letting the customers to have their decisions, on to buy or not?
Best regards.

4

Design (and amount of features) matters in the CSS category. It’s more about design than code in there.

Also ThemeSLR is not a reviewer so trying to convince him otherwise won’t do anything. :stuck_out_tongue:

1 Like
5

Yeah, i know :stuck_out_tongue: :stuck_out_tongue:
I Just feel that there is something :fish: here… :\

6

That was my personal opinion! An an Author I think design makes your item approved on ThemeForest.

So, for me its pretty simple: Bad design = Hard Rejection :slight_smile:

P.S: There is always place for improvements, so @saltkod , as I said before, first of all compare your work with some approved items; You will see what to improve if you are a good designer.

1 Like
7

TRUE! :joy:

8

What do you think is fishy? If I was a reviewer, I also would have rejected the item in question. It does have a nice look and feel, but it’s too simple. It feels like something I can find on the net for free from stack overflow or some tutorial blog site, you know what I mean?

1 Like
9

Yes, i understand. I know you are right no that.
I was only showing my rage… :joy:

Best regards.

1 Like
11

With respect, there are freebies out there that deliver more features and better execution.

  • lacks obvious drop down examples

  • would be better if there was something to the settings, login, sign up options e.g. a form to show consistency

  • attention to detail e.g. “fixed bottom” and “form” option and then click “profile” the pointer still points upward not down. There is zero room for any error in such a simple item

  • attention to detail “simple version” different padding/margins at either end

2 Likes