I’ve came a long way since my last asking for feedback thread 4 years ago Back then I was asking reviewers to not make me modify / ruin my item by forcing me to make it more mainstream. Fortunately I succeed, and so did the item on the marketplace (3971 sales so far).
As almost all my items sell better then neighbor items, I was hoping Envato owe me a little trust for my judgment. I uploaded new item and it was soft-rejected. Not big deal, except the suggestions for improvements were so general, they weren’t much help. For example:
…overall design quality and pay more attention to details
But as soft reject is defined:
Soft Rejected means that the item is almost ready to go up for sale on Envato Market, however the item still needs a couple of small changes before it can be accepted.
I’ve tried to find out what exactly reviewers expect. It took me a couple of months now (and dozens of changes). The last feedback doesn’t sound very softy:
The main issue still lies on the fundamentals of the design which looks dated, generic and unfinished.
At this point I think it would be better if it was hard-rejected in the firs place. Obviously we have different opinions on what my customers look for.
Anyway, I try to make the last effort to make it approved. And as reviewers doesn’t really provide any specific suggestions, and make me wait at least few days for every reply, I ask you guys for some help.
- Is it worth fighting for this item?
- What improvement suggestions do you have for me.