I did submit my theme a month ago. Since then, i constantly get requests for improvement design. I’ve corrected it several times (even existing design table is very different from the first version). I feel tired with the auto mail from reviewers :
"Overall, this is a good concept but there are a couple issues here: Minimal templates can be clean and simple when you manage to handle the white space and details to provide a simple but yet unique template. But if you can’t, it will look like an incomplete template – blank template…"
I spent a lot of time for this. I need a few comments from other authors. Any solution this issue !
This is my link theme : Here
Thank you for feedback. I’m thinking about it, but I feel very difficult to break the original design, and i almost hate comments from auto mail of Reviewer. It makes me astray …
hello friend
check your theme by theme checker plugin like this type
and also check after wp debug Active
and i think here your http://monalisa.alenastudio.com/ this page content more theme not more design template in 1 theme so if this type so please create all theme separate and create 1 theme have more than 1 template for home ,shop , portfolio
THanks
Thanks, i don’t know they are soft reject what layout theme … ( medical, porfolio or real estate … )!? I just get a general comment …
"Overall, this is a good concept but there are a couple issues here:
Minimal templates can be clean and simple when you manage to handle the white space and details to provide a simple but yet unique template. But if you can’t, it will look like an incomplete template – blank template.
In this case, the submitted template is more like a ‘framework’ than a full fledged design. If you’re going with minimalism, you need to make sure all the little details check out…"
I pay a lot of time for it (more than 1 month from the submit time).
a little patience … they will accept it Try to fill places where is to much of blank space and logotype really doesn’t look good on retina, make it bigger and scale it by script - then it will looks soft on Retina and I think that they have mostly Mac’s to review.
Last time I get soft reject with:
overall quality need improvement
usability
readability
That was hard to fix … and I just delete it and start to create new
Just change what the reviewer said because I got hard rejection after the 4time soft rejection It had really made me angry But I think sometimes reviewer is right because after you make changes you’ll see the clean rusult yourself. Just don’t change too much : ) Keep going
I understand … I was here about 2 years ago in Marketing section. But also You must try to understand that it’s very hard to say what is wrong … He/She look at theme and they do not feel it, but they see that You can fix something, add some details, and this bring new life to the theme …
I also was so many times so angry on reviewers when I look at some other accepted themes …
I have also stucked almost month for my prev themes. They said just like those text. I think it’s PreMade placeholder like auto mail However you just need to compare to other accepted themes to your own theme.
I don’t know why Your Google fonts are not working. Envato Reviewers Reject if your theme used too General Fonts such as Raleway or Open Sans combination or something too general things used in that theme. Nowadays they Approve only Unique something Special Standin features and Design and Typography.
Design need to be fresh and well Typography, also elements need to be Unique.
I think your Demo’s Hover Effects and Element Designs need to be consistent and Typography need to be fixed some areas.
I think the Main issue is Typography and Hover Effects.
However you just need to compare to other accepted themes to your own theme.
And you can for example the few places that I have fixed typography?