I’m really confused.
This track got rejected the first time, so I asked for some advice here on the forums.
This was the original version:
I received some great feedback regarding the mixing and arrangement, so I improved it, and posted it here again to ask for feedback on the new version before re-submitting it. There were some more suggestions on small changes, so I improved some more aspects as well.
This is the new version (2 different lenghts):
Turns out it got rejected again.
I really don’t understand this. They give us no reason for why it’s rejected, and ask us to get feedback on the forums, which is what I did. And then after improving the track I ask for feedback again before sending it and it seemed to be ok, according to the other authors here. But since I can’t get an actual feedback from the reviewer, it’s hard to really know what’s wrong with the track just from the other authors opinion.
Well, sorry for the vent and long text.
I’d like to ask if there’s still any major, noticeable problem in the song that could be preventing it from getting accepted? Or is the problem the song itself?
Should I just stop trying to improve or fix this track for this purpose, and just try working on another one?
I’d also like to say I’m really grateful for the feedback I’ve received, because it really helped to improve my track from what it was before, regardless of getting accepted or not.
Thanks once again.
EDIT: links fixed