Hard Reject On my Item. Please Advise

Envato Authors CodeCanyon
1

Hello,

I am a new author and i uploaded my item on codecanyon but it got hard rejected with no reason. The email they sent below.

Hi codeguru43,
Here is a sample of your items reviewed for the day.

Hard rejected (1)
SocialSwap - Marketplace for Buying and Selling Digital Accounts

I believe this is a mistake and i will like your opinion as to why my item has been rejected. Here is a link to the Demo - https://socialswap.codeguru.pro. Documentation - https://docs.codeguru.pro…

I will really appreciate your feedback. Thank you

2

Probably has to do with the fact that selling TikTok and certain other channels/profiles is not allowed so this encourages illegal activity

4

There is a similar product on codecanyon at the moment and it was approved. Overrall, is my UI good please? Or is there another reason?

5

There is a similar product on codecanyon at the moment and it was approved. Overrall, is my UI good please? Or is there another reason?

6

Can you share the URL?

7

This is the url to the similar script

8

No. There’s no UI as it looks unfinished. This is probably the main reason if it has enough features/functions.

9

Please can you tell me why you said it is unfinished? This is the link to the demo and I don’t really understand what exactly you saw that made it look unfinished. https://socialswap.codeguru.pro

It has a lot of features, atleast most of the things that users will want in a script like this. And I intend to also update it regularly with more features.

10

Please can you help?

11

I cannot help, since these decisions seem completely random, but I came to say it doesn’t look unfinished to me.

12

Your site looks pretty finished to me. and I think the ui is not that bad and well feature prof. I don’t really know why they will hard-reject it. What did use building it ? The technologies? And what category did you upload to. And why does evanto operates this way they should at least ruled out some potential improvement even tho they will not accept the item. It will Make authors improve on their upcoming projects

13

I’m really not sure why it was hard rejected since no feedback was given with the rejection. I used Laravel, tailwind, alpine. I used good technologies so I doubt if that’s the case. For the category, I uploaded it to the php category. I just assumed whoever handled my review was probably in a bad mood that day because I really don’t see any reason it was hard rejected outright.