Videohive item has been rejected

This two project has rejected.
Need your vision: what is wrong in this items,
Will approve them if I improve them.


Thank you!

first one look too flat. I like how the logo appear. it just looks un-finished. the second one looks good but, there are tons of those items on the market. this one does not shine among the crowd.

that is my opinion.

I am on your shoes. I got one item soft rejected and then hard rejected. I made a post about it.
this one!