Item was soft rejected, then hard reject rejected after review

Envato Authors CodeCanyon
1

Hello,
I have posted a product of mine in code canyon 2days ago. I thought this item is good enough for codecanyon. No similar item available in codecanyon But I was shocked when they rejected my item. I’m also a level 5 author with 4 approved items. So guys please give me feedback on where need to improve my item. Here is the link to my item

Frontend: https://boomchart.net/sandbox
Admin Access: https://boomchart.net/sandbox/admin
Admin Login: Username: admin || Password: 1234
User Access: https://boomchart.net/sandbox/login
User Login:Email: demo@boomchart.net || Password: junejune

2

What was the original soft reject motivation from the reviewer?

3

Screenshot 2020-11-01 at 06.59.32
Screenshot 2020-11-01 at 06.59.322874×1674 527 KB

screenshot of the full conversation

4

they really had no reason to reject this

5

It doesn’t seem like to be a proper way to reject that item? But anyway reviewer has the right to approve or decline any product based on the products code and it’s quality.