It seems like every time I weigh in on something in the forums, I start by saying I’m both an author and customer, but it’s applicable, so here’s my take.
The previous popular files page was far better than the “new and improved one” currently on display. My opinion isn’t based on my desire for things to never change. I’m all for working to improve the customer experience, but I do not think this does that in any way, shape or form.
I found it easier to browse the page and easier to find a track quickly (on the occasions I used the page for this purpose - I don’t always buy tracks this way) with the previous page design. I have heard some complaints on the forums about the old small play button on the author thumbnail. I don’t share that opinion. I think the old setup worked well, and if I wanted to get the full details on a track, I clicked on it.
I don’t need to see everything related to the track immediately in front of me. It’s too much, especially with multiple tracks displayed in this way.
I think minimizing author branding should be a non-starter when it comes to deciding on changes to the interface that buyers use. It shouldn’t happen. Authors have a huge challenge trying to stay relevant, visible, and viable under the best circumstances.
Reducing author logos to the current size used in the redesign makes no sense and certainly does not serve authors’ interests.
The 2018 Envato Annual Public Impact statement included the core value statement, “When the community succeeds, we succeed.” According to the statement, community is comprised of customers, the company, staff, stakeholders and authors.
Please remember that authors are supposed to be included in the community.