Be very careful with Envato, because they don’t give any reason which is really explaining why your good quality item is rejected, we work on our products for months and submit all files to Envato, then wait for result, how will you know if they don’t give you any explanation for hard rejecting your item you submitted, what if they modify and use your codes in their system or sell them somewhere else?
Here is my item rejected below and they just saying it doesn’t meet their quality requirements!
and here some same kind of products which accepted in CodeCanyon:
[removed: please don’t call out items or users]
Demo page of this item doesn’t even work! And there is exactly same product in github made by someone else! even in comments customers say this that this product is stolen from github! Author don’t even reply to these comments!
Here another item that meets Envatos quality requirements!
As you can see this product is also very simple version has no originality but accepted by Envato!
I am not crying here because my product is rejected but it is my first time here and their system has many wrongs to say, they don’t give a real reason for rejecting and they also say you can’t submit same item again! They should tell you why they reject your product and give you other chance to correct these mistakes and apply again, but no! this system sucks and very suspicious, Will Envato give me any guarantee that is my code i’ve sent them is not copied and will be used by them? Don’t tell me they are so rich so they don’t need this, Also what is logic if you compare my product with other ones, who can say other ones meet quality and not yours!(One product exactly has free github version made by somone else and it doesnt even have demo, author dont even reply, another one is so simple and ugly looking but still met quality requirements)
If an item is rejected it is very bad that they don’t give real reasons for this. They should say for what reasons this product doesn’t meet their quality requirements! But hey! no answer from Envato!