Soft rejection on Menu Template…seeking feedback

Hey everybody

I just had one of my Restaurant Menu soft-rejected. I have 4 files in AI CS6 and 4 files on EPS format.

And here is the comment of reviewer:

When you set up page spreads, the best way to provide the templates to the buyer is to keep each page spread in its own file. This is much easier to work with than hiding/showing layers that represent the different pages. The reason page spreads make the most sense instead of single pages is due to how printers require the item be sent to them and also due to the fact that its easier to modify a design spread and add text that spans the pages.

That mean i must combine 2 single page into 1 rite? But my idea is the buyer can use invidual page and free to combine it like what they want.

Need an advise, thank you and sorry for my bad English

Here the design.

Any help? Thank you

@TuanCFS any comment by reviewer ?

the comment: When you set up page spreads, the best way to provide the templates to
the buyer is to keep each page spread in its own file. This is much
easier to work with than hiding/showing layers that represent the
different pages. The reason page spreads make the most sense instead of
single pages is due to how printers require the item be sent to them and
also due to the fact that its easier to modify a design spread and add
text that spans the pages.

As per the reviews comment what i understand is.

you have x no of pages which are all in a single psd / some file… he is telling you to make each page in to a seperate files for eg

Hompage.psd
aboutus.psd
others.psd.

for now he is telling that you all made in a single psd and used layers. for it. so its good if you separate it

Thank for your help, but i already have 4 seperates file name 01_page1, 02_page2, … etc. I always did it on my final artwork because my idea is customer can combine it to whatever thay want. And i do not have any problem when send for approve so in this case i dont understant what reviewer mean.

Ho ok then have you given any variations for a single page.

eg :
Home page with slider
Home page without slider

if yes and its all in a single psd. try moving those into separate file and submit it for review :slight_smile: it may work