Hi @imriky
I don’t think it’s bad, but I also don’t think it’s enough.
There are quite a lot of logo mockups that are essentially just the flat logo on some paper with a bit of the texture showing through. Again, not saying it’s a bad thing, it’s just been done a lot and are usually offered alongside other mockups as a sort of mockup pack.
For example, I took a quick look at some others on the marketplace and I think this is a good example.
From what I understand, reviews are also based on the uniqueness and demand of an item, so if you do something too similar to what’s been done tons of times before, then it will likely be rejected, even if it’s of the same quality because it doesn’t have as much of a commercial value as something more unique would.
One slight critique though. The paper texture seems to blur slightly as it gets closer to the bottom, however, the logo isn’t blurring the same way, causing it to be disconnected from the paper.
If you want to do more logo mockups, I would suggest trying something a bit more on the creative side rather than simplistic.