Hi fellow authors,
My track was hard rejected and I cannot find out why. As you know, the curators provide nothing but a broad message and the suggestion of asking for help from the forum. So please…help! What is wrong with my track?
Thank you for your help 
Hey there,
What I hear is way too much middle in the rhodes/e-piano. It sounds boxy and intrusive (almost painful to me).
Same with the whistling, it just doesn’t sit in the mix well. Maybe the rhodes/e-piano (soloing at 1:12) should be omitted from the track entirely and leave only the acoustic piano, it sounds much better. Less is more. 
And that brings us to the last point, the whole track should be shorter. It’s too repetitive to me.
Cheers!
The musical idea is interesting, but I agree with SixideBeats and I find it too long and too repetitive also. Plus the timing of the instruments is off in some places. (I understand that it’s a jazzy piece with jumpy chords, but it could benefit from more tightness, I think). Good luck next time!
Hey SixideBeats,
Thank you for the feedback. It is quite useful.
Wish you much success
Hi Nonzerobot,
Nice to read your comment. It is important for me to have same kind of outside opinion.
Much success
Hey! great piece!
Maybe reviewers think its too good for audiojungle
Hey nikitsan,
That is a very motivating comment. Thank you.
Wish you much success