Hard Rejects, Need Feedback


I really need feedback as to why these are rejected? Are they too similar to other stuff on the site? I am getting the same generic rejection over and over and just want some more info.

Item 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z2b2HPmXmYU

Item 2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPmz-fgx8zc


Video 1: Black shadows look dirty. Frames look too rough. There is no any final scene with the logo or text. Looks too simple.
Video 2: It doesn’t bring something new to the market. There are hundreds of similar projects on the market. And it’s too simple.


Okay, thanks! I appreciate the feedback.

While I have you, could I get your opinion of this intro? https://youtu.be/CaxBlia92jU