[Hard Rejection] Please help us!

Due to lack of responses I try again.

Our theme for WordPress has been hard rejected. We’re pretty frustrated, as there are several reasons, we don’t understand. This was their feedback:

  1. Design elements are not consistent, theme uses more than one.
  2. Design is not aesthetically pleasing.
  3. Usability is pretty poor.
  4. Theme seems unfinished too.

We are of course thankful for the feedback, but we’re at the same time confused, as the reasons are not specified.

Here is the demo: http://dlrthemes.com/demo/pencilcase/

Please help us improve the theme!