Hello dear colleagues.
We need your constructive criticism of your template.
We have developed a template Iwiki Admin v1.0.0 (current v1.3.2) and after loading on TF, we were given a Soft reject.
http://91.234.35.26/iwiki-admin/v1.0.0/admin/index.html
First they sent this:
This is a unique submission and very different than most Admin Templates submitted to ThemeForest. However, the quality needs some additional work. While the overall design is working, smaller details (the elements, components, widgets, etc) need more attention to detail. Focus on improving the quality at a lower level and this item has great potential.
After making the required fixes or improvements, please edit your submission at WordPress Themes & Website Templates from ThemeForest and submit for re-review.
Please note, you must make the required fixes or improvements before resubmitting for re-review. By not doing so, repeated resubmissions without changes may be considered abuse of the review system and your submitting rights may be disabled.
After that, we released version 1.1.0
http://91.234.35.26/iwiki-admin/v1.1.0/admin/index.html
After the version 1.1.0
They sent us that our image quality is poor.
We fixed it and made the version 1.1.1:
http://91.234.35.26/iwiki-admin/v1.1.1/admin/index.html
They sent us the following:
Unfortunately the changes are not enough. The overall structure of the design is great and I’m enjoying the unique direction. The big issue lies in all of the minor details.
Screenshot on 1.25.2016 at 12.59.58 PM.png - Droplr
Screenshot on 1.25.2016 at 1.00.09 PM.png - Droplr
Screenshot on 1.25.2016 at 1.00.18 PM.png - Droplr
Screenshot on 1.25.2016 at 1.01.08 PM.png - Droplr
Screenshot on 1.25.2016 at 1.01.22 PM.png - Droplr
Focus on improving the spacing, alignment, hierarchy and overall quality of the small sections before resubmitting.
We have fixed a lot of things, added a lot of elements and released version 1.3.0:
http://91.234.35.26/iwiki-admin/v1.3.0/admin/index.html
And we came again:
THE CHANGES ARE NOT ENOUGH: Unfortunately, the changes are not enough and the previous review still stands. Please carefully check your item to make sure all problems were adequately addressed before resubmitting this item.
After making the required fixes or improvements, please edit your submission at WordPress Themes & Website Templates from ThemeForest and submit for re-review.
Please note, you must make the required fixes or improvements before resubmitting for re-review. By not doing so, repeated resubmissions without changes may be considered abuse of the review system and your submitting rights may be disabled.
We have fixed a hierarchy of elements on the pages on the basis of other patterns, but in the end after all we got Hard reject. http://91.234.35.26/iwiki-admin/v1.3.2/admin/index.html
Dear colleagues, look with fresh eyes what is wrong and write about it in the comments, we’ll be very grateful!
Thank you so much!