Help selecting a classified theme

Hi , How are you fellows doing today .

I am having hard time selecting a classified theme from the following two of them .

Basically i am trying to build a pets classified site

Both are almost similar . Please guide me on what to look for before choosing .
Any help would be great .

Classified themes are very rare … i look here and in google for week i found only around 7 good quality … but still nothing match what i need … i will have to request custom one soon… im now just trying to find the best way to describe it bcz its very hard for noob like me describe something like this…