Feedback please!

Hey, I’m a noob! I uploaded my first track 8 days ago and got completely and utterly rejected. After doing a little more self-critiquing I can understand why they might have rejected it, but their vague reasoning is still a little frustrating. It just took me by surprise. I didn’t realize this site had such high standards, but I would rather have it that way! Now if I can just get accepted… :laughing:

I thought it might be a good idea to ask for some feedback BEFORE uploading my next track, so I can spare myself the agony of waiting 8 days to be casually toss aside. Any feedback would be much appreciated!

Hi there,

I am listening it on a headphones, mix/master is not very good, low frequencies are distorted in some way as I can hear. Also melody and harmony are very unusual. I don’t get in which category this track can fit. It’s instruments are from different songs, everyone plays on its own. Lead is to harsh ( 2:21), crash is too loud. Also try to find better quality samples. I hope other guys will tell you their opinion.

Good luck mate!

1 Like

Thanks for the feedback :slightly_smiling_face:
I was trying for a House category track, guess I didn’t quite hit the mark…

Some good ideas but the mix is a total mess.

Good idea.!
1.More simple .
Sometimes to many instruments do the same think.
2.Mix is not the best.
3.intro is to long.

Good luck.:grinning: