Want to learn from hard reject

Envato Authors Graphics Authors
1

Hi, so looking to get some feedback from my hard reject about two uploads, my first two uploads actually.

I designed 2 logo’s. One vector, the other is a picture with text. Both are editable in photoshop and other programs. The font was included, from fontsquirrel, free to commercially resell.

Thanks for the info.

1_Bike repair shop logo
1_Bike repair shop logo1920×1920 76.4 KB

2_The Lions Club logo Luxurious
2_The Lions Club logo Luxurious1920×1920 238 KB

2

Don’t get me wrong but the first one and the second one looks like it’s been designed by different people. Apart from that:

  • First one is too simple. It looks like it’s icon
  • Second one is too complex. It should be uploaded to some other category. (not exactly the same )
1 Like
3

The lions look like AI generated image

4

I was thinking the same ( AI ) but he mentioned it’s editable. I assume it’s not.

5

I hope you will get success too.

6

Why are so many rejections? Interesting.