why Envato reviewer keep rejected good themes??

Envato Authors Theme Authors
, ,
1

i put a lot of effort and time on this theme and in the end, i got rejected.
i fix all the required issues from Envato theme check plugin and i also run unit test for my theme and all it’s good and in the end, i got a hard reject !!!
this is my theme demo please take a look at it : https://tastypress.infinitypressthemes.com/

2

@Infinity-pressthemes

Sorry for I say you… your design is too basic error typography, too dificult read, too small typography, spacing, etc you need more quality design will to be approved themeforest.

3

sorry but i don’t agree with you cuz they’re much worse themes in the same category now

4

good, you ask other author.

Regards.

5

Sorry, you don’t can copy idea other design similar, you need make more original and unique themeforest will to approved.

6

Hi,

No envato market does not reject good quality item.
I saw your item as my opinion your item lots of issue like spacing and alignment, typographic hierarchy, visual hierarchy, low contrasts etc…

Need to more study and research about themeforest latest quality items.

Thanks!

2 Likes
7

Fatal validation errors = immediate rejection

8

what? any more explanation, please!

9

i don’t copy anyone’s ideas, come on you can do better than that!

10

thanks!

11

https://validator.w3.org/nu/?doc=https%3A%2F%2Ftastypress.infinitypressthemes.com%2F

This needs fixing especially as there are early issues and further errors cannot be checked

12

ah ok, did you think that’s the reason of rejection?

13

If the reviewer saw that then they probably wouldn’t have checked the rest

It’s definitely one cause

I can only see it on a phone but the typography definitely looks like it could be improved.

It’s an ok concept but there’s nothing there which is not already for sale in many other items

14

ah, i will give it another try! thanks charlie

15

this the message from review team
Unfortunately ‘WordPress’ has higher standards in terms of aesthetics. As higher quality items become available in the marketplace, approval requirements will increase to maintain appropriate marketplace quality.

While I’d be able to provide feedback as to how to get this approved, I can only do after it has crossed a certain threshold, quality wise. I’m sorry to say this isn’t there yet.

16

Hi,

A few small tips:

  1. Don’t use too small font size (for example, “Our history” section).
  2. The handwritten font has bad legibility in combination with small font size. Consider choosing another one or use it only for large titles.

Good lack!

2 Likes
17

i will consider that, thanks!