Tracks rejected, requesting feedback

Hello!

Here are two tracks that got rejected and I don’t understand, why. Is this an arrangement issue or does it have something to with mixing/mastering? Feedback would be appreciated so I can correct my mistakes next time.

Hi @BlueMongoose!
I think whistling is off tune a little.
Maybe try to do better mix, use better instruments. It sounds a little cheap.

Hi!

Thanks for the input! I’ll work on the things you suggested in the future. Cheers!

Good luck!

It’s always a good idea to use a bit of autotune on whistling. Believe me, not all of us can do it properly in tune. Cheers!

It’s always a good idea to use a bit of autotune on whistling. Believe me, not all of us can do it properly in tune. Cheers!

Good idea! I’ll try that . Thanks!