Theme hard reject while psd was approved for this category (need reply from reviewer)

item-feedback

#1

Hi everyone

What happen for review system,
As always I created my psd before create theme until have not hard reject. nevertheless 2 time my theme hard rejcet by this mesage
"The overall quality of your submission does not meet our aesthetic and technical requirements and will need to be improved before being resubmitted."

I only change little thing for better view, please guide me what i must do
Thanks

psd:
https://redpen.io/wvf3d86116e567297e

theme:
http://themes.persitheme.com/smallblue/


#2

NO any help?


#3

:sweat: :rage:


#4

Looking awesome. The reviewers are getting weird and rude. They are not thinking about your efforts just keep rejecting the items.


#5

I don’t see a PSD or HTML version for sale in your portfolio for this?


#6

Hi, as I said it was not ready for psd category but it can approve fot other category like wordpress.
this is usual fo my items, I create first psd and after get verify for wp category I create theme


#7

Thank you :grinning:


#8

Did the reviewer suggest that you should code this to WP instead?

With all due respect (and if the reviewer told you otherwise then they know better than me), it looks very very outdated and lacks both premium feel or anything unique/stand out to distinguish it from the rest of the marketplace.

It also seems very similar to your other ‘blue’ file from last year.

Just my opinion of course.


#9

These are part of 2 and 3 of my trilogy on blue items and these get verify for other category not psd about 1 month ago
I explain it for reviwer and they verify them

https://redpen.io/wvf3d86116e567297e

https://redpen.io/bwb371ff71fdfc40a2


#10

See what they say but bear in mind the first one for WP was on April 2014 and things change.

good luck


#11

Thanks :grinning:


#12

I need reviewer reply, please help meeeeeeeeeeeeeeee :scream: