Static Homepage Help

Hi - I’m trying to change my homepage and the static page option does not seem to be capturing my updates. I’m using the Soledad theme. I have an old homepage selected under Settings - Reading - Your Homepage Displays (A Static Page). I created a new page using Elementor and when I select the new page to be my Static homepage, the new page is not seen by anyone else as the homepage. When I go to customize the appearance, I see the new homepage I created in Elementor, but no where else can some one see it outside of customization. I’ve tried clearing my cache through the dashboard and checking on multiple browsers in private mode so cookies are not impacting what I see. Anyone know why making changes to the Static Page option is not working for me? Thanks!