First of all, thank you @Atamotion for your response and clarification
But I would like to respond to the points that you indicated, but we must agree that all authors without exception search for projects that have achieved success in sales and then design their projects based on the criteria for which those projects have succeeded, and I also found projects that have achieved very good sales (And it deserves it) even though based on the points you mentioned, it is not worth selling!
First, see the example
It is also a simple project, the text in the middle, and there is a repetition in the movement and there are no significant variation in the movement of letters, although it is still beautiful and achieves excellent sales, that is an indication that customers like this kind of work.
Therefore, the first point I do not see is correct.
Secondly, boredom exists in hundreds of projects presented in Envato, and sometimes I cannot complete a video preview, even though it has been sold dozens of times. What I and you see a boring work, that other people see fit for them.
although it does not boring.
For texts, go back and see the example and you will see my response.
Thirdly, you are completely right, I have missed this matter, and if this was the reason for the refusal, it was easy for them to alert me to this until I correct it and the matter is over.
The fourth point, you could not catch the movement, I did not move the letter (o) from the far left to the far right, see it well or see the word (easily) you may be able to know the movement that i made.
Note: The movement you referred to is in a previous project that was previously approved in Envato, see my Portfolio.
There is no basis for your opinion.
As for the example that you gave me, it is indeed a wonderful work, but if it was shown to one of the reviewers of Envato and was in a bad mood, the author would find this in his inbox:
Thank you for your submission. We have completed our review of “example” and unfortunately we found it isn’t at the quality standard required to move forward, and you won’t be able to re-submit this item again.
It may be because of the inability to read the text, see the time 1:22