My logo was rejected. The standard answer from Envato contains the following phrase: "you won’t be able to re-submit this item again".
My question is: When is a logo already considered different? I edited the logo in many aspects: composition, details, font, colors (see picture: before and after).
Can the edited version of the logo be considered “different”? Can I submit this new version again?
It doesn’t look like a logo. It looks like several combined vector icons. The logo should be concise, and you have a lot of elements that do not carry any meaning. There is no any idea. Just a primitive graphic drawing
Sorry, I have not read your text.
I don’t think that it will be a violation if you submit the new logo. But what’s the point? The problem is that the mistakes that I indicated are in the first and second versions. The second logo will be rejected for the same reasons as the first one.
The point is that I have seen many approved logos with the same “mistakes”. The logos with many “iconic” elements that may look without an idea from the first sight. But…
In my humble experience, a logo is evaluated not by a commission of professional designers but by a client. This is a subjective assessment, and the client can use the logo for various purposes, and he/she can change the logo to suit his needs.
Therefore, I always see the point. The most important thing for me in this context is not to break the rules. And it’s all
he followed some of the things that i pointed but not all and i think his question was legitimate as hard to identify , sometimes, in my view, if the changes are subsequent enough to b able to resubmit