“Hard rejected” on AJ, what’s wrong with this track? - Summer Walking loop
From my own pattern of rejects/approvals, I`d guess two things:
Your Vienna whistler is too prominent in the mix, overbearing everything else, and as a consequence, feeling hollow, not as pretty as solo instrument should appear, sitting in the mix.
Despite the ideas you`ve tried to bring into the music, the arrangement is static, and I sense its one of the major checklist items with AJ reviewers now. The musical idea could be simpler, but overall impression should be of “breathing” piece, where stuff happens. As a music theoretic with a degree in the field, I would also agree, that for a casual listener, different instrumentation elements, small changes etc. would be much more apparent than strictly melodic/harmonic development. I guess we all need a balance between the two
Hope you nail it next time!
Hi! I agree with @Soundlufs. Static arrangement (that make track to boring) and whistle. Try to make your song more dynamical and I hope it will be ok for AJ. Good luck!
Thanks for advice, but the duration of this track - 30 seconds. This is a loop, which MUST be static for this duration. For example.
Another one rejection without any reason. What’s wrong with this track?
Really nice track! On the phone it sounds like a steel string without a use of a pick. Maybe that.
It is true that once upon the authors-sellers have been invited for “reviewing”? And now the authors-sellers reviewed the other authors-sellers?