Movie Logo hard reject. What do you think about this one?...


#1

I work as an art director in the design company many years. And I do not understand what is wrong with this wonderful logo. Here is an idea, correct geometry, unusual name. Envato needs such a logo. But they rejected it.
The following items better then my artwork? I do not think so. I need your opinion. How can I upload my logo and make Envato professionals to explain me why they approove worse logos and reject better???

(item links removed)


#2

Linking to other authors and their work and calling it worse than yours is just rude.

You logo is very nice but your attitude sucks.


#3

May be you right. But Envato testers rejected my work not cause of this…


#4

but at least the guy had a good comment from me , because that’s nice a work and original too … and quite frankly i guess that MoaRose did not go through so many pages because there’s far worst …


#5

hi, they may not reject your item for this reason but this is not a good reason to do that to others … besides, try to think about it, would u be happy if some others guys did about your work? i guess not … authors are a community here as much as they can , pls just try to remember about this


#6

for me , your work is good and should have been accepted , the concept is not highly original but the thing is very nice and professionally executed according to me , however, maybe i am wrong about it , but u know here they enjoy having much of a work about typo (which doesn’t always make sense by the way …) and they may have rejected because they consider that the typo is a bit too plain … as for me u have a good harmony like this and people do not need to have fonts coming out of nowhere for creating a harmonious and professional logo and as for me your logo works well … . Now, what i advice u to do is just to make the most of the fact that u have lots of other possibilities for you to post your logo design somewhere else , so that u don’t lose it … i am sure that some other place will welcome it