Guys, do you have a list of minimum requirements which reviewers probably have (or we suppose they do not have any list and items are approved just according to the reviewer mood).
Don’t you think that this is ubnormal that items are rejected without any detailed information? I could understand when we get soft reject with some notes, but getting hard reject of theme which has no drastical differences comparing with existing approved themes - that throw us off our stride.
Dear @reviewers don’t you mind to share with theme authors your opinion about that? Probably creating of accessible list with mimimum requirements will simplify your life and authors will bring you high quality products at once and approvement process will not take so much time (it is also a huge trouble when theme is approving for more than 1 week). Just simple checklist which make life of both sides (authors and themeforest community) happier.