Impossible to get accepted

wordpress

#1

3 days ago I got soft reject with one “bug”. Now I got soft reject with 3 “bugs”.

I check my theme with Theme Check plugin and it’s ok, no errors, but reviewer send something like this. Is this some joke?

  1. Please make sure that your template doesn’t raise any PHP errors, notices or warnings on activation. Enabling wp_debug can help you with this: http://envato.d.pr/By6F/4IJL8xk3 (Found on a post with comments)

  2. 150px image is stretched, e.g. http://envato.d.pr/16c3p/1zQf8YsY - on my server, localhost is not …


#2

Think if these issues raised by some of your customers in the term of review :slight_smile:
Keep submitting with changes, and you will be get accepted very soon i am sure - good luck.


#3
  1. ok fixed it was typo and that’s why I ask about update theme on other topic

  2. impossible to repeat - I put image by wordpress admin button - display ok… i upload image by < img > tag from different server , looks ok… how other way I can upload image to post ?


#4

It seems that you are enjoying blaming reviewers rather than proper homework before theme submission.

Why? Here are few :

** Undefined variable error

Shouldn’t be there, not reviewers fault.
Simply check with clean install, you will get those errors if you are still not getting.
Browse all pages. Check debug .txt file. Most probably you will get even more esp. undefined variable / undefined index

** Image issue / no space paragraphs etc.
It is already known that you should import WP demo data and test at least for few basics like images / paragraph.

https://codex.wordpress.org/Theme_Unit_Test

** data-validation-issue / Directory Path / sanitize URL / add_shortcodes() not allowed in theme etc.

Discussed many times and should have been considered before theme submission.
It is not wise to be dependent ( esp. ) on reviewer at least for commons.


#5

I say that I fix this but waiting more for update theme them soft reject - just similar post do not show because of typo in variable

I do not see it … 150x150 works ok after import data. And why I blame reviewer? Because in last soft reject I got 1 “bug” … why he can’t check also this and I must lost next 2 days when everybody knows that first review takes 60 days. Creating theme for TF will soon takes about half of year if every reviewer will send you only 1 “bug” every 2 days.


#6

And why I blame reviewer? Because in last soft reject I got 1 “bug” …
why he can’t check also this and I must lost next 2 days when everybody
knows that first review takes 60 days. Creating theme for TF will soon
takes about half of year.

Again same.
A highly discussed topic previously, especially by those who get more than 2 soft rejections :wink:

It is author who has to make error free theme, not reviewers responsibility. We cannot blame someone else for which we are responsible.

You have 1 theme - still miss many things, how to expect from reviewer ( themes to review count certainly not 1, 5 or 6 ) everything at one go. They don’t get list of errors created automatically buddy!

Once you note these down and keep eyes open to current trends, even direct approvals are possible.

About Image : Have you tested adding images by ‘Add Media’ with left alignment and text wrapped around?


#7

Yes I try.


#8

Then what is reviewier responsibility? I thought that checking for “bugs”, requirements ? Bad must be reviewer that see only 1 error and second see 14.


#9

Bugs for WP Importer:

Strict Standards: Redefining already defined constructor for class WXR_Parser_Regex in /Users/xxx/Sites/wp303/wp-content/plugins/wordpress-importer/parsers.php on line 408



Strict Standards: Declaration of WP_Import::bump_request_timeout() should be compatible with WP_Importer::bump_request_timeout($val) in /Users/xxx/Sites/wp303/wp-content/plugins/wordpress-importer/wordpress-importer.php on line 38

Notice: wp_get_http is deprecated since version 4.4! Use WP_Http instead. in /Users/xxxx/Sites/wp303/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3658

Notice: wp_get_http is deprecated since version 4.4! Use WP_Http instead. in /Users/xxx/Sites/wp303/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3658

Notice: wp_get_http is deprecated since version 4.4! Use WP_Http instead. in /Users/xxx/Sites/wp303/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3658

Notice: wp_get_http is deprecated since version 4.4! Use WP_Http instead. in /Users/xxx/Sites/wp303/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3658

Notice: wp_get_http is deprecated since version 4.4! Use WP_Http instead. in /Users/xxxx/Sites/wp303/wp-includes/functions.php on line 3658


#10


#11
  1. Theme does not translate all strings. e.g. http://envato.d.pr/9z6I/5cQ3Ei4j

Really???


#12

I bet time concentrating on your theme would have helped the quality greatly, instead of steaming off here :slight_smile:


#13

Yes I learn a lot ,but not in programming - but in meeting the requirements of the TF which no one really knows. 5 different application tester check my theme and every one have different requirements ,but they have nothing to do with script.


#14

What is to question there?
Yes, all strings should translate, even alt comes under this.

Are these lines from your theme code? If yes, then hard coded alt for logo…:disappointed: