Feedback Needed: Hard Rejected Mystery Box – Spin & Win Prize Script (Core PHP)

Envato Authors Code Authors
1

Hi fellow authors,

I recently submitted a project titled “Mystery Box – Spin & Win Prize System with Dynamic Odds | Core PHP Gamified Reward Script” to CodeCanyon, but unfortunately, it received a “hard rejection” with the standard message saying it doesn’t meet the quality requirements and cannot be resubmitted.

The script is a fully responsive, gamified mystery box system built entirely in Core PHP (no frameworks). Users spin a wheel and win prizes based on set probabilities. The admin panel allows managing prizes, users, transactions, and settings. It mimics the feel of a native app on mobile browsers.

Here are the live demos:

→ User Demo: https://mysteryking.wowcodes.in
→ Admin Demo: Admin Login

  • Username: admin@wowcodes.in
  • Password: Admin@WowCodes

I’m genuinely looking to improve. I would really appreciate honest feedback from experienced authors:

  • What do you think may have caused the rejection?
  • Is it the UI/UX, code quality, idea originality, or something else?
  • Is the idea too niche or already saturated?

Any constructive criticism is welcome. I’m committed to learning and making my next submission better.

Thank you in advance!

2

@WowCodes

If I made a calculated guess then probably it was rejected because you may have failed to explain enough about the script at the time of submission. I am not sure about the gambling aspect of it either, but I can see other items for sale on the marketplace. Cannot check admin area because it is asking for an activation key.

I don’t have enough experience in this area to offer you a constructive response. On the front end it looks okay on a computer screen. Also unfinished images not impressive.

3

@123Simples
Can you please try now? I have activated it with a purchase key. Admin Login

6

@WowCodes

I’ve just closed and unlisted this topic. Only you and I will see the issues shown below - apart from mods.

I logged into your admin panel -
Initial page looked great
Second page users NOT SO GREAT.

screenshot.5222
screenshot.52221812×389 60.6 KB

screenshot.5223
screenshot.52231048×590 24.7 KB

Using Firefox Browser.

I think you have an issue :slight_smile: