Envato Elements, Perfect for Users, Terrible for Authors!!!

Hello to all designers and developers,

Unfortunately, since 2018 and after the introduction of Envato Elements, we have seen a significant decrease in sales and income. From 2018 to 2024, about 75% of market sales have decreased, and we are approaching the complete destruction of sales in the market. You can see sales reduction charts in this post.

The significant decrease in the income of authors has caused the development of products for the Envato market not to be economically justified, and large teams are no longer willing to design products for Envato. As a result, we will only see weak and low-quality products in the market in the future. Many authors have also stopped their activity in Envato. Designing and developing a professional WordPress theme takes about 6 to 12 months for a professional team. Is it worth developing it with this low income?!!!

We have built our business based on Envato Market as a full-time job and unfortunately, we are now witnessing the decline and destruction of our business. We are very worried and disappointed about the future of our jobs here.

Several factors have caused the decline in sales, such as competitor markets, AI, and other platforms. But the biggest decrease in sales is related to Envato Elements subscription model!

Here are some points.

  1. Why Envato market grew a lot compared to other competitors and why do designers and users prefer this market to other markets?
    In recent years, Envato market, especially ThemeForest and CodeCanyon, has grown significantly, and users and authors prefer it to other competitors. The reason for this was that the income of the market was reasonable and appropriate for the authors and they designed new and professional products in competition with each other and developed their professional teams to operate in the market. As a result, due to the presence of professional products in this market, users also preferred to buy from this market.
    But now unfortunately, because of the sharp decrease in income, professional teams can’t develop a top-quality product, and as a result, we will have a market with low-quality items, and then users would move to other markets.

  2. Why was the Envato Elements subscription model created?
    Other markets that were not able to compete with Envato, introduced their subscription model to attract users at a low price. Envato, fearing to lose the users, so in a similar action, designed the Envato Elements subscription model to attract users!
    But the important point here is that other markets were full of low-quality and copied products, and they still could not compete with Envato. So users still bought from Envato.

  3. Access to millions of digital items, unlimited downloads, and infinite projects, just by paying $16 ($11 for students) ?! This causes a sharp decrease in income!
    In the Envato Elements subscription model, the user has access to millions of items such as WordPress templates and plugins, codes, photos, etc by paying only $16 ($11 for students) and can design infinite projects with them. Even after the end of the subscription period, he can design his projects unlimitedly with the items he has downloaded.

  4. A sharp decrease in the income of market and elements authors!
    Previously, the user used to pay about $100 to design a website, including the WordPress template, required plugins, photos, etc. But now, by paying only $16 ($11 for students), he can design unlimited projects. This is great for the user but terrible for the authors!
    This greatly reduces the income of the market and elements authors.

  5. Null website owners steal items easily!
    Now, by paying only $16, null website owners have full access to all items and copy them to their website for free downloads or sale!

As a result, Envato Elements has severely reduced the income of both market authors and Elements authors. Considering that Envato is focused on Envato Elements and promoting it everywhere, soon the entire market will stop selling and we will all be forced to move to Envato Elements, which only earns a small amount of money. As a result, we are forced to leave Envato.

I believe that the Envato Elements was a terrible decision and will destroy our business!

Please invite other authors here to participate in this discussion and express their opinions about Envato Elements. Also, we should look for a solution to solve this issue, otherwise, our business will be destroyed soon.

12 Likes

Envato Elements sales are decreasing too. It destroys itself too! Earning chart for an author from Envato Elements. Source

3 Likes

I’ve said this from day one.

Envato is not about quantity is about quality, if SS decides to make CC and TF with a subscription model Envato will die completely… clients already lost faith in Envato due to the mess of the new CEO…

3 Likes

This obviously terrible model turned out to be terrible?! Who could have possibly known?!

3 Likes

Please invite top authors to contribute to this thread so maybe we can find a solution.

Since last month, when the new Envato Elements was unveiled and advertised in the header and footer of the market, our sales have decreased by 30% compared to the previous month. If it continues like this, the sales of the market will stop altogether and the income of Elements will be very small and it will not be worth to continue and spend time in Envato. Therefore, we will be forced to leave Envato and find another job, and the business we have worked for for years will be destroyed!

4 Likes

The problem is that the people who make decisions think about just growth. They don’t think about what makes Envato work and the long term outcomes of their decisions. They get more money and don’t think about everything else, like the fact the money comes from selling off cheaply everything that has been created.

2 Likes

Envato did not do this from fere, since the new CEO was in charge the communication between authors and the management completely stopped is if we were employees, not contributors and our opinion did not matter, I think they did this to close shop, they were tired of making money the opt guys and sold out, SS bought Envato to kill competition, they willl move everything to a subscription model or just remove TT and CC saying that is not profitable anymore who knows what goes in the brain of this CEOs man…

For me, it makes no sense to destroy such a place intentionally and what is worse is that authors all jumped on Elements like it was a golden duck, now they complain is not working anymore, it was a failure from day one!

There was a discord group about creating a new marketplace I am interested, is it still on?

Even now if top authors will jump on these discussions we could make a change but nobody cares anymore…

2 Likes

I didn’t care about the group too, a lot of uncertainty and distrust in the authors. In my experience there have been smart authors but most of them are long gone.

1 Like

I am strongly opposite of Envato Elements for Themeforest & Codecanyan! If they don’t stop it, we lose all our income and have to leave the Envato soon.
While the Envato Elements banner is everywhere, how do you expect to sell on the market?! Now, all traffic goes to the Elements.
As a user, what do you prefer? Pay $16 to access a million WordPress themes, plugins, codes, templates, videos, images, add-ons, etc., or pay $59 for a single WordPress theme! It’s funny! We do not have any way except to join the Elements and earn a few dollars just for a hobby!
Actually, Envato Elements was terrible news, especially for web developers and designers! Most of us have to leave the market soon. I promise.
Just look at the advertising banners on the market! You just see Elements!

  1. Sticky Top Bar
  2. Submenu in Top header Bar
  3. Main & Bold Menu Item
  4. Again A Submenu
  5. Main Section Big Banner Between Items
  6. Footer Big Banner
  7. Footer Menu Item

1 Like

Elements revenues also ended the videohive side. We have completely separated from our team as a stock video and graphics creator, but I occasionally upload things to my personal account, hoping it will get better.

1 Like

So if Elements is destroying the marketplace and itself why push it so much I just don’t understand the thinking behind this mess!

2 Likes

I believe the responsibility lies with us, the authors. Aren’t we the ones responsible for uploading our work to Elements for such low prices? They wouldn’t have introduced Elements if our fellow authors hadn’t agreed to it. What’s needed is unity to stand against companies like them, but unfortunately, that’s not happening. Only a few of us are raising concerns, while others simply view the posts or sometimes leave a like and move on, afraid that Envato will retaliate if they speak up.

3 Likes