Critisize rejected item please?

What is wrong and how to improve?

This is beautiful. Sad to know this was rejected

1 Like

I haven’t done any classical music mixing but I don’t know is it a good idea to pan instruments in an asymmetrical way in stock music. I mean melody is panned to left and all other harmonic instruments panned to the right. Great composition but it is a bit weird like this.

1 Like

Thank you for your kind words! I put in this an efforts and personally like it and thought it will surely be approved… But the reviewer thinks different. :frowning:

Hm, maybe you are right. I’m not experienced in orchestration but I thought to place the instruments according to traditional European sitting of orchestra to get panning realism is a nessesary rule: violins far left, cellos so-so right, violas wide close to center. The violins play the melody, so I don’t know if there other ways to solve the stereo imaging.