Can we argue to our rejected items..?

hi all,
i,ve items that kind of popular on graphicriver,
and I tried to make some similar design to push sales. but, it rejected by reviewer. can we argue and make some reason so that came up to my portfolio…?

first item on market

second item that rejected


My opinion is that the second item suits better as an addition to the first item. Because concept-wise it brings nothing new, so therefore not original or different enough to become a new item.