Call for Collis Ta’eed, Envato founder:Please Separate Elements!!


1 Like


Even if we all agreed on something, they’ll find a way to turn it against us (meaning make us earn less, not kill our families, even it can be related at some time) and make themselves more profit, so please guys for once, settle with what we got, so that this thing can be f stable for at least a year. Thanks.

Hi @BenLeong @jamesgiroux

I just want to emphasise the exclusivity question many authors have asked already in this thread and other threads.

Except better commission, what are the benefits of being an exclusive author versus non exclusive under the current Elements advertising? This might be the most important question Envato needs to answer in my opinion.

I can’t be the only one who find it weird that Elements, which is non exclusive, is isolated and free from market advertising. Basically treated like an exclusive library.

Many have focused on how Elements authors is exploited in a one size fits all model. I don’t want to fire up that discussion here. At least as an Elements author this is your own choice and you can opt out at anytime.

Another uncomfortable question is:

Are the exclusive market authors literally paying for the advertising of this competing library from their own pockets with lost sales?

If so, then maybe exclusive market authors are those who really are being exploited here?

Thanks in advance for giving us some feedback and thoughts in this thread. I really think Envato owe the community some transparency here.


Hi, I totally agree. Authors as me an others are working very hard in external promotion for years (Including payment ads, footage, stock images, etc.,) in order to get more sales or referral earnings. If someone arrive to audiojungle following one of my hundreds referral links that I have in internet and he decided to “click” on this “elemments” banner and try the subscription model I don´t receive a penny for this new subscriber. I lost a sale and also a referral earning because Envato don´t cover a referral earning by this way. What is the business for me to continue promoting audiojungle /envato? @collis @emilie_b


I have raised this same question on the forums before, and it is an important one. Many authors have chosen to set up shop here exclusively and have supported and promoted this marketplace for years.

Envato is presently making strategic choices that they obviously feel strongly about and feel are necessary for their own viability.

Unfortunately, those choices are diminishing the benefits of being an exclusive author here.

In fact, you could probably make a good argument that there has never been a worse time to be an exclusive author at a marketplace - when that marketplace is actively and continually using its considerable promotional resources to move website visitors away from your portfolio to a newer, cheaper licensing platform (Elements subscription).

I don’t have the exact wording of a staff post issued prior to the addition of audio to Elements, but I could swear that post assured authors that it was not Envato’s intention to poach customers from the marketplace.

Presently, their actions appear to directly contradict that statement.

It feels like (please correct me if I am wrong) Envato is doing everything possible to grow the Elements subscriber base by advertising directly to buyers that often have initially arrived at the marketplace to browse your portfolio and purchase a sync license or two from you at your marketplace rate.

It is unfortunate, but we are at a point where Envato’s goals are not aligned with those of many of the authors who have been their loyal, exclusive partners.

I am an AJ author and a 10+ year Envato customer who has purchased thousands of licenses (music, SFX, WordPress themes, videos, photos). As such, I am often included in research studies and asked to share my opinion on surveys.

No matter how I have filled out those surveys in the last couple years, there is always one question that I can’t give them high marks on anymore.

“Would you recommend the Envato marketplace to a friend or colleague?”

I don’t answer “no” out of spite. It’s an honest assessment of my current experience here.

Being vocal (and critical) about this doesn’t make me any friends higher up, I’m sure - but I haven’t been here this long for no reason. I have been a customer, a seller, and a fan of this company for many years.

I think authors deserve a bit more consideration, transparency and professional courtesy if they have chosen to enter into an exclusive agreement and sell their best work here at an Envato marketplace.

We all want Envato to succeed. We would prefer that the price of that success not be the diminishing of our own businesses.


You are totally right!!!


I support ! 100%

1 Like

still no answer from envato


1 Like

So still nothing from Envato? We can plus 1 this thread till we have grandchildren, but if no one from Envato is even willing to reply…

1 Like

+1 did not work, thats why we are trying +2 :wink:


I applied to technical support with about the same requirements. You know what happened? My accounts have been blocked. Here is and solve as here belong to authors.

Everyone has seen films about the middle ages.

There is a Kingdom and the Kingdom is ruled by a king.
The king is strong and wise, he wants happinesses prosperity for his people.
But the king has advisers and assistants who give him advice - how to do better. The king feels in his heart that he should not do what he is advised to do, but the advisors say-it is necessary, so we will show our strength, etc.

War begins, people die. But advisers keep telling the king " if we do not do so, the enemies will think that we are weak."

In the end, the war is lost those with whom there was a war coming… Well then everything is clear.

There are also good advisers, but most often the king does not listen to them)

King, please listen to your heart that has brought you to the throne.

Still no awnser. It reminds me a song title from Björk…


I’m in!


1 Like

Me +2!

I support, my sales fell down on 75% in february. :’-(




Aggressive advertising of Elements is very disappointed me. At the summer meetup James was telling that it’ll be two independed market… But now it’s like store with iPhones advertises Xiaomi or something like that.

1 Like

Now i see they put advertising banner for “Placeit” - unlimited video downloads in my author page. “Elements” banner was before.

1 Like