I agree that AJ was not intended to be a student sandbox. However, the thread here is not about teaching how to do, we are not asking to write what kind of instrument need to be used and what frequency need to be cured. One word - “equalization”, or maybe “arrangement” is just enough to move further. There was a situation when I submit two similar tracks (instruments, style, mixing) and one was approved, the second was hard rejected. I didn’t know what to do and just left rejected track laying on my HDD “as is”, untouched.
Another problem here I see is that if an author asks for a help here on forum - it’s almost a guesswork for my opinion, because nobody can tell for sure that THIS IS the problem as a reviewer considered from his point of view. So, you’re right, @NVolkov , that we don’t get a request to fully rework a composition, but in case of total “blindness” and uncertainty we are forced to do that.
1 Like